
The problem
Symptom. A retailer rejects a batch of clear PET trays because a hazy circular disc shows through the label at the centre of every base, visible only under the goods-in light booth.
What it costs. At 40 000 trays per order, a 6 % cosmetic reject and a re-inspection hold cost more than the heated plugs that would have prevented the mark.
This guide shows how to measure plug chill marks, set a plug-to-sheet temperature difference, and write a label-zone clarity clause into the purchase order.
- 1. Reading the mark: chill blush versus a true gauge defect
- 2. Measure plug temperature and mark depth before changing the cycle
- 3. Plug material, temperature and contact time to specify
- 4. Process variables that bring the mark back after sign-off
- 5. A label-zone clarity test for the purchase order
- 6. Costing heated plugs against a permanent cosmetic reject rate
Reading the mark: chill blush versus a true gauge defect
A plug chill mark is a local gloss loss, not a thinning fault. On 0.6 mm APET it reads as a 2-8 µm matte disc, 20-40 mm across, centred on the plug axis.
| What the inspector sees | What is physically happening | First measurement |
|---|---|---|
| A matte disc centred on the base | Plug chilled the contact patch below the PET forming temperature | Plug face thermocouple vs sheet temperature, 30 shots |
| A ring or halo, not a solid disc | Plug dwelt long enough to freeze an orientation gradient | Contact dwell time from the servo log |
| Mark only on alternate cavities | One plug heater or felt cover is out of specification | Per-cavity plug temperature map |
| A sharp crease, not a soft blush | Plug too fast, folding the sheet instead of stretching it | Plug entry speed and vacuum delay |
Table 1 - Classifying a base mark before adjusting the former
Need a fixed price for this formed tray?
Send the tray drawing, sheet gauge and annual volume. We will review draft, trim and material, then quote a production tool with a written line-acceptance test.
Get a thermoforming quotationEmail [email protected]WhatsApp
Measure plug temperature and mark depth before changing the cycle
Log plug-face temperature over 30 shots, then measure the mark by stylus profilometry at 5×. We usually find a 28 °C plug against a 92 °C sheet, a 64 °C gap that prints a disc.
A five-step diagnostic sequence
- Map the plug temperature.
Log plug-face temperature over 30 shots at production cycle rate, not on a cold tool. - Measure the mark.
Use stylus profilometry at 5× to record depth in µm across the label zone. - Tag by cavity.
Compare marks across every cavity to separate a plug fault from a sheet fault. - Sweep contact dwell.
Run 0.2, 0.4 and 0.9 s dwells and plot mark depth against dwell time. - Hold the acceptance shot.
Retain 30 approved trays under D65 light as the visual reference for goods-in.
The chart below is a typical result from that measurement step. Use it to separate a design limit from a setting that can still be recovered.

Plug material, temperature and contact time to specify
Specify plug temperature, dwell and entry speed. Hold the plug within 15 °C of the sheet, dwell under 0.4 s and entry near 0.5 m/s; a 0.9 s dwell prints a ring every shot.
| 매개변수 | Typical target | What goes wrong outside it |
|---|---|---|
| Plug-to-sheet temperature difference | ≤ 15 °C | A cold plug chills a visible matte disc into the base |
| Plug contact dwell | ≤ 0.4 s | Longer dwell freezes an orientation ring around the plug |
| Plug entry speed | 0.3 - 0.8 m/s | Fast entry folds the sheet instead of stretching it |
| Mark depth in label zone | ≤ 3 µm | Deeper marks read through the label under D65 light |
Table 2 - Plug assist parameters to write on the tool specification
Process variables that bring the mark back after sign-off
Even a qualified tool drifts back. A worn felt cover, a 10 °C cold-start heater drop, or a lot with 3 % higher crystallinity all widen the gap, so log plug temperature per shift.
| Process variable | Effect on the mark | Practical control |
|---|---|---|
| Plug felt cover worn past 0.5 mm | Local contact pressure rises and blush returns | Replace covers on a shot-count schedule |
| Heater output down 10 °C on cold start | Sheet-to-plug gap widens above 15 °C | Warm-up interlock before first good shot |
| Sheet crystallinity up 3 % | Haze contrasts more strongly against the mark | Qualify the tool at both resin-lot limits |
| Vacuum delayed 0.3 s | Plug stays in contact longer and prints a ring | Lock vacuum delay in the recipe |
Table 3 - Process variables that restore chill marks after sign-off
A label-zone clarity test for the purchase order
A drawing cannot describe a chill mark, so add a functional clause: no visible disc under D65 at 500 mm, depth below 3 µm, verified on 30 trays from every cavity and three lots.
Want the tray checked against your line?
Send us the tray drawing and the line conditions. We will flag the geometry and material choices that cause jams, and quote a tool with an acceptance test.
What to send us
- Tray drawing with draft and radii
- Sheet grade and gauge
- Stack depth and line speed
- Drawings of the magazine or denester
Costing heated plugs against a permanent cosmetic reject rate
Heated aluminium plugs with closed-loop control cost roughly £1 800-3 000 per tool but remove the 6 % cosmetic reject. Against a 40 000-tray order, rework and hold costs repay the change within two batches.
Before you sign off this thermoformed tool
- Plug surface temperature and its control method are stated on the tool specification
- A maximum plug-to-sheet temperature difference of 15 °C is agreed at first-off
- No visible disc in the label zone under D65 at 500 mm is written into the acceptance clause
- Mark depth is measured by profilometry, not judged by eye alone
- Approved reference trays from three sheet lots and every cavity are retained
A tray that looks right in the carton can still stop a filling line. Test the stack, not a single part.
Can a hotter sheet hide a cold plug?
It reduces the contrast but not the cause. Raising sheet temperature to 100 °C while the plug stays at 28 °C still leaves a 72 °C gap and risks sag. Heat the plug itself and close the gap to within 15 °C.
Why do only some cavities show the mark?
Almost always one plug heater, felt cover or air line is out of specification. Map plug temperature per cavity; a single cold station prints a disc while its neighbours stay clear.
Is a syntactic-foam plug better than heated aluminium?
Foam plugs insulate and reduce marking but wear and drift with shot count. Heated aluminium with closed-loop control holds a stable 80-90 °C face and is easier to qualify for a cosmetic clause.
What magnification should goods-in use?
A 5× loupe under D65 at 500 mm catches discs that a naked-eye check misses. Pair it with a profilometer limit of 3 µm so the decision is a number, not an opinion.
Will the mark disappear after the tray is filled?
No. The disc is a surface-gloss change fixed into the PET, and a chilled or labelled base often makes it more visible. Reject it at goods-in rather than hoping the contents hide it.
How many trays should the acceptance sample cover?
Thirty trays from every cavity and at least three sheet lots, checked under D65 at 500 mm with mark depth recorded. Cosmetic faults cluster by cavity and lot, so a single-tray sample proves very little.
Get a tray that runs on your filling line
Send us the tray drawing or a sample stack. We will review draft, trim and material, then quote a production tool with a measurable line-acceptance test written into it.
To get an accurate quote, send:
- Tray drawing or sample stack
- Sheet material and gauge
- Line speed and denesting method
- Annual volume and target unit price
Request a tool and tray quotation
Prefer to talk it through first?
이메일 [email protected] or message us on WhatsApp +86 177 1752 9949. Send a drawing, a sample or a specification and an engineer will reply.
Why buyers work with Uplastech
ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 certified. Founded in 2016, with injection moulding lines in Shanghai and an extrusion plant in Jiangsu. Moulding machines from 90T to 1100T and a maximum shot weight of 5100 g. Samples and a written quotation are available on request.