When a Bigger O-Ring Extrudes: Gland Overfill in a Hydrostatic Test

Real moulded silicone seals and O-rings made by Uplastech
Real silicone rubber production context. Uplastech product photo.

The problem

Symptom. After a weep complaint, a buyer approves a larger cross-section O-ring for the same groove, and the new seals extrude and nibble during the routine hydrostatic acceptance test.

What it costs. The substitution that was meant to guarantee a seal instead fails a witnessed pressure test at goods-in, so an entire assembly batch is held and the drawing is disputed.

This guide calculates gland fill, links overfill to extrusion through the clearance gap, and gives a gland and acceptance-test clause to put on the drawing.

Why a bigger O-ring can seal worse

Gland fill is seal cross-sectional area divided by groove area. Above 90 % there is no room for thermal expansion or swell, so pressure drives rubber into the clearance gap; at 0.2 mm clearance and 100 bar the seal extrudes and nibbles.

Finding at the pressure test Most likely cause Confirming measurement
Chewed lip on low-pressure side Extrusion into the clearance gap Measure nibbling depth after the test
Seal split along its circumference Gland fill above 100 % Recalculate fill from the drawing
High assembly force, twisted seal Overfill, no room to seat Check installed squeeze and groove volume
Leak only at peak pressure Gap too wide for the hardness Measure diametral clearance at 100 bar

Table 1 - Reading an extrusion failure after a hydrostatic test

Record which of these you are actually seeing before changing any setting. Two faults can look identical on the line and need opposite corrections.

Need a fixed price for this seal?

Send the gland drawing, temperature range, media and annual volume. We will recommend a compound with test data and return samples with a written production quotation.

Get a silicone seal quotationEmail [email protected]WhatsApp

Calculate gland fill before changing section

A hydrostatic acceptance test at 100 bar for 30 minutes shows the failure clearly: the extruded lip is chewed back on the low-pressure side. The chart below plots extrusion depth against gland fill; damage rises sharply once fill passes 85 %.

A five-step diagnostic sequence

  1. Recover the approved drawing and the change note.
    Confirm which cross-section was substituted and whether the groove was redrawn at the same time.
  2. Recalculate gland fill from measured groove dimensions.
    Use the actual groove depth and width; a 5.33 mm section in a shallow groove exceeds 100 % fill.
  3. Measure diametral clearance at test pressure.
    Record the gap under 100 bar; a gap above 0.15 mm needs a back-up ring or a harder compound.
  4. Inspect the failed seal's low-pressure side.
    Nibbling or a chewed lip confirms extrusion rather than a simple leak path.
  5. Repeat the witnessed test on five assemblies.
    Hold 100 bar for 30 minutes and measure extrusion depth against the 0.10 mm limit.

The chart below is a typical result from that measurement step. Use it to separate a design limit from a setting that can still be recovered.

When a Bigger O-Ring Extrudes: Gland Overfill in a Hydrostatic Test: calculated response trend and an illustrative root-cause split
Figure 1 — Calculated response trend and an illustrative root-cause split. Values are engineering guidance for diagnosis, not a measured survey; confirm them on your own line before changing a drawing or a specification.

Read extrusion damage from a failed pressure test

Calculate fill from the drawing before any substitution: a 3.53 mm section in a 2.6 mm by 4.8 mm groove sits near 75 %, but a 5.33 mm section in the same groove exceeds 100 %. A section change demands a groove redraw.

Parametro Typical target What goes wrong outside it
Gland fill 75 - 85 % Above 90 % rubber extrudes under pressure
Diametral clearance at 100 bar Below 0.15 mm A 0.25 mm gap lets the lip nibble
Hydrostatic acceptance hold 100 bar for 30 min Shorter tests miss slow extrusion
Maximum extrusion depth 0.10 mm Deeper nibbling fails the witnessed test

Table 2 - Gland and acceptance parameters to put on the drawing

Set the gland and clearance limits on the drawing

Specify gland fill between 75 and 85 %, a diametral clearance below 0.15 mm at 100 bar, and a Shore A 70 compound for the larger gap. Write the 30-minute 100 bar hydrostatic test with a maximum 0.10 mm extrusion limit into the purchase order.

Option When it fits Trade-off
Revert to the original cross-section Substitution caused the failure Does not address the original weep
Fit a PTFE back-up ring Gap or pressure cannot change Extra part and assembly step
Redraw the groove for the larger section Higher squeeze genuinely needed Machining change and new first article
Reduce clearance below 0.15 mm Tooling allows tighter fit Tighter machining tolerance

Table 3 - Corrective paths after an overfill extrusion failure

Myth: "A process adjustment will fix it." Once a design limit is reached, more tuning only adds cost and variation. Confirm the limit with a measurement, then change the drawing or the specification.

Choose a back-up ring instead of more rubber

Where pressure or gap cannot be reduced, a PTFE back-up ring closes the extrusion path without adding rubber volume. Fitting one to the low-pressure side of a 90 % fill gland typically cuts extrusion depth from 0.5 mm to under 0.05 mm at 100 bar.

Want a compound check before you re-order?

Send us the gland drawing and the service conditions. We will compare the compound data against your temperature range and return a recommendation with sample parts.

What to send us

  • Gland dimensions and cross-section
  • Temperature range and media
  • A failed seal if available
  • Annual volume

Send the gland drawing

Recovery actions ranked by line disruption

Recover the held batch by reverting to the original section and adding a back-up ring, then repeat the witnessed 100 bar test on five assemblies. If the drawing cannot be changed, reduce test pressure only with the customer's written agreement and document the extrusion depth.

Validate one change at a time and keep the measurement record. A supplier discussion backed by data is resolved in days, not weeks.

Before you release this silicone seal

  • Gland fill is calculated and stated on the drawing, not assumed from the seal section
  • Any change of cross-section triggers a groove redraw and a new first article
  • Diametral clearance is specified at the test pressure, not at room conditions
  • A 30-minute 100 bar hydrostatic test with a 0.10 mm extrusion limit is in the purchase order
  • A back-up ring is specified wherever the clearance cannot be closed

Most cold or heat failures are specification gaps, not bad batches. Fix the specification before changing suppliers.

Why did a bigger O-ring make the leak worse?

More rubber raised gland fill above 90 %. With no room for expansion, pressure pushed the seal into the clearance gap, where it extruded and nibbled instead of sealing.

What gland fill should I target?

Between 75 and 85 % for a static radial seal. That leaves volume for thermal expansion and fluid swell while keeping enough squeeze to seal.

Can a harder compound stop extrusion?

It helps: a Shore A 70 compound resists the gap better than a 40 or 50 grade. But hardness cannot fix a 0.25 mm clearance at 100 bar; a back-up ring or tighter machining is needed.

What does extrusion damage look like?

The low-pressure side of the seal is chewed back, with small crescent-shaped bites of rubber missing. It is distinct from a clean cut or a compression split.

Is a back-up ring better than redrawing the groove?

A PTFE back-up ring is quicker and keeps the existing tool, often cutting extrusion depth from 0.5 mm to under 0.05 mm. A redraw gives a cleaner long-term design.

Should we lower the acceptance pressure?

Only with the customer's written agreement. The test exists to reproduce service pressure; lowering it hides the overfill rather than fixing the gland.

Get a seal specified for the real service conditions

Send us the gland drawing and the service conditions. We will recommend a compound with documented test data, review the squeeze, and supply samples with a production quotation.

To get an accurate quote, send:

  • Gland drawing or seal cross-section
  • Temperature range and media
  • Pressure and movement
  • Annual volume and target unit price

Request samples and a quotation

Prefer to talk it through first?

Email [email protected] or message us on WhatsApp +86 177 1752 9949. Send a drawing, a sample or a specification and an engineer will reply.

Why buyers work with Uplastech

ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 certified. Founded in 2016, with injection moulding lines in Shanghai and an extrusion plant in Jiangsu. Moulding machines from 90T to 1100T and a maximum shot weight of 5100 g. Samples and a written quotation are available on request.

Hi there! I'm John, dad and hero to awesome kid. By day, I'm a plastics manufacturing vet — injection molding, extrusion and vacuum forming — who went from factory floors to technical management. Here to share what I've learned—let's grow together!
it_ITIT

Chiedete un preventivo rapido

Inviare disegni e requisiti dettagliati via

Emial: [email protected]

Oppure compilate il modulo di contatto qui sotto: