
The problem
Symptom. A flange assembled with a 2 mm silicone gasket passes a 2 bar air test but is rejected when a helium check at 1 bar returns 5e-5 mbar l/s against a 1e-6 mbar l/s limit.
What it costs. The gasket and bolt load are correct, yet an undefined surface finish on the flange drawing lets each machined batch leak differently, so the delivery and the tooling are disputed.
This guide links helium leak rate to Ra and tool lay, sets a surface-finish window, and gives a finish clause and acceptance test to put on the gland drawing.
Why roughness, not just squeeze, sets the leak
Helium follows tool marks, so flange roughness, not only squeeze, sets the leak rate. A 2 mm gasket at 20 % squeeze seals a concentric Ra 1.6 um lay, yet a radial Ra 6.3 um scratch leaks 5e-5 mbar l/s.
| Helium-test finding | Most likely cause | Confirming check |
|---|---|---|
| Leak worsens as Ra rises | Continuous radial tool marks | Read the lay direction on the trace |
| Mirror-polished face also leaks | Gasket cold-flow and slip | Measure Ra below 0.4 um |
| Leak fixed by more torque | Finish channel, not low load | Re-test after re-machining to Ra 1.6 |
| Leak at 2e-7 mbar l/s | Concentric lay, 20 % squeeze | Accept against the 1e-6 limit |
Table 1 - Reading a flange-finish leak-rate dispute
Need a fixed price for this seal?
Send the gland drawing, temperature range, media and annual volume. We will recommend a compound with test data and return samples with a written production quotation.
Measure Ra and the tool lay
Measure the flange with a stylus profilometer at four points, logging Ra and lay, then helium-test at 1 bar for 10 s. The chart below plots leak rate against Ra for two tool lays against a 1e-6 mbar l/s limit.
A five-step diagnostic sequence
- Log the drawing and the finish note.
Confirm whether Ra and lay were ever written on the gland drawing or only quoted in an email. - Measure Ra and lay at four points.
Use a stylus profilometer; record Ra 0.8-1.6 um and the tool direction relative to the seal. - Helium-test the assembled joint.
Hold 1 bar helium for 10 s on five flanges and record leak rate in mbar l/s. - Re-machine one flange to the clause.
Bring it to Ra 1.6 um concentric lay, then re-test to show the leak drops below 1e-6 mbar l/s. - Agree the acceptance record.
Put Ra 0.8-1.6 um, concentric lay and the 1e-6 mbar l/s limit on the purchase order.
The chart below is a typical result from that measurement step. Use it to separate a design limit from a setting that can still be recovered.

Specify the surface-finish window
Specify Ra 0.8-1.6 um with a concentric lay, 20 % squeeze on a 2 mm gasket, and a helium leak below 1e-6 mbar l/s. Above Ra 3.2 um radial channels open; below 0.4 um a polished face lets the gasket slip.
| المعلمة | Typical target | What goes wrong outside it |
|---|---|---|
| Flange roughness Ra | 0.8 - 1.6 um | Above 3.2 um radial channels leak |
| Tool lay | Concentric to the seal | Radial marks give helium a path |
| Gasket squeeze | 20 % on a 2 mm section | Below 15 % the gasket cannot fill valleys |
| Helium leak rate | Below 1e-6 mbar l/s at 1 bar | A radial scratch reaches 5e-5 mbar l/s |
Table 2 - Surface-finish and leak parameters for the gland drawing
Put the finish clause on the gland drawing
Write the surface finish on the gland drawing, not in an email: Ra 0.8-1.6 um, lay concentric to the seal, no radial scratches, and a 1e-6 mbar l/s helium limit at 1 bar. Require a profilometer trace and a leak certificate per batch.
| Option | When it fits | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Re-machine to Ra 0.8-1.6 um concentric | Radial or coarse finish | Machining time and scrap |
| Add a PTFE envelope gasket | Finish cannot be changed | Extra part and cost |
| Raise squeeze above 20 % | Rarely sufficient | Over-compression, faster creep |
| Write a 1e-6 mbar l/s clause | Future orders | Narrower machining options |
Table 3 - Corrective paths for a rough-flange leak
Confirm with a helium leak test
Confirm the clause with a helium mass-spectrometer test at 1 bar for 10 s on five flanges machined to Ra 1.6 um concentric lay. A joint reading 2e-7 mbar l/s passes with margin; re-machine any flange whose radial trace breaches the 1e-6 limit.
Want a compound check before you re-order?
Send us the gland drawing and the service conditions. We will compare the compound data against your temperature range and return a recommendation with sample parts.
What to send us
- Gland dimensions and cross-section
- Temperature range and media
- A failed seal if available
- Annual volume
Close the claim with a profilometer trace
Recover the held lot by re-measuring Ra and lay on four points per flange and re-testing at 1 bar helium. If the finish is outside 0.8-1.6 um, re-machine rather than adding torque; tightening the joint only hides a continuous scratch.
Before you release this silicone seal
- Ra 0.8-1.6 um and a concentric tool lay are dimensioned on the gland drawing
- Radial scratches across the sealing face are explicitly prohibited
- A 20 % squeeze on the 2 mm gasket is stated with the groove depth
- A helium test at 1 bar for 10 s with a 1e-6 mbar l/s limit is in the purchase order
- A profilometer trace and a leak certificate are required per production batch
Most cold or heat failures are specification gaps, not bad batches. Fix the specification before changing suppliers.
Why does a rougher flange leak more?
Radial tool marks form a continuous channel from the bore to the outer edge. A Ra 6.3 um radial scratch can pass 5e-5 mbar l/s even at 20 % squeeze.
Can a very smooth flange be as bad?
Yes. Below about Ra 0.4 um the polished face gives no grip, so the gasket cold-flows and slips, opening a leak. Target 0.8-1.6 um.
What squeeze should we specify?
20 % on a 2 mm gasket, compressing it to 1.60 mm. Too little squeeze leaves valleys unfilled; too much accelerates creep and relaxation.
What leak limit is realistic?
Below 1e-6 mbar l/s at 1 bar helium. A concentric Ra 1.6 um lay typically reaches 2e-7 mbar l/s, comfortably inside the clause.
Will more bolt torque fix a rough flange?
No. Extra load hides a continuous scratch without sealing it. Re-machine to Ra 0.8-1.6 um concentric lay and re-test.
How do we prevent a repeat dispute?
Write Ra, lay direction, squeeze and the helium limit on the gland drawing, and require a profilometer trace and leak certificate per batch.
Get a seal specified for the real service conditions
Send us the gland drawing and the service conditions. We will recommend a compound with documented test data, review the squeeze, and supply samples with a production quotation.
To get an accurate quote, send:
- Gland drawing or seal cross-section
- Temperature range and media
- Pressure and movement
- Annual volume and target unit price
Request samples and a quotation
Prefer to talk it through first?
البريد الإلكتروني [email protected] or message us on WhatsApp +86 177 1752 9949. Send a drawing, a sample or a specification and an engineer will reply.
Why buyers work with Uplastech
ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001 certified. Founded in 2016, with injection moulding lines in Shanghai and an extrusion plant in Jiangsu. Moulding machines from 90T to 1100T and a maximum shot weight of 5100 g. Samples and a written quotation are available on request.
Continue reading
- Silicone compression set
- Silicone gasket and seal design
- Silicone hardness: Shore A
- Silicone industrial seals
- Silicone o-ring manufacturing
Ready to specify? See our silicone rubber moulding services أو request a written quotation.