Flame Retardant Compounds: Halogen, Phosphorus and Aluminium Hydroxide

Grey and white flame retardant plastic pellets in two steel sample trays beside a laboratory cone calorimeter, on a clean workbench
The compound that passes the test is not always the one that keeps the properties.

What a flame retardant has to interrupt

Burning plastics is a cycle. Heat breaks the polymer into flammable fragments, the fragments burn and release more heat, and the heat breaks more polymer. A flame retardant works by breaking one of those links: by absorbing heat, by diluting the fuel, by forming a barrier that keeps heat out, or by interrupting the radical chain reaction in the flame itself.

Every commercial system is a combination of those mechanisms. The three main families differ in which one dominates. Halogenated systems work in the gas phase and interrupt the radical chain. Phosphorus systems work in the condensed phase and promote a char. Metal hydroxides work by absorbing heat and releasing water, which dilutes the fuel and cools the surface.

The practical difference is loading. A halogenated system might achieve a UL 94 V-0 rating at 12 to 18 parts per hundred. A phosphorus system might need 15 to 25. Aluminium hydroxide needs 55 to 65 parts per hundred, which is a different material rather than an additive, and it changes every mechanical property in the table.

That loading difference is the whole decision. A system that works at 15 parts leaves 85 percent of the formulation for the polymer. A system that needs 60 leaves 40, and the polymer is no longer the continuous phase in the way the design assumed. The mechanical consequences are proportional to the loading, not to the chemistry.

Halogenated systems

Halogenated flame retardants, usually brominated or chlorinated compounds used with an antimony synergist, are the most efficient per unit weight. They work in the gas phase, quenching the radicals that propagate the flame, and they are effective at loadings that leave the polymer's mechanical properties largely intact.

Their weakness is the smoke and the corrosive gases they produce. Hydrogen bromide and hydrogen chloride are toxic and corrosive, and they attack electronics and metal structures in a fire. That is why halogenated systems are excluded from most of the electronics and transport markets, and why the search for alternatives has been driven by regulation rather than by performance.

They also have a processing window. Brominated compounds can decompose near the processing temperature of some engineering resins, releasing hydrogen bromide into the melt, which corrodes the screw and barrel and causes a visible discolouration. A stabiliser is usually part of the package, and the melt temperature has to be respected rather than pushed for cycle time.

For a product where the specification allows halogen and the loading has to be low, they remain the most effective option. The decision is regulatory and commercial, not technical: where halogen is permitted, it works, and where it is not, no amount of reformulation makes it acceptable.

Phosphorus systems

Phosphorus based flame retardants work mainly in the condensed phase. On heating they decompose into phosphoric acid species that catalyse the formation of a carbonaceous char, which insulates the polymer below and holds the fuel in. They are effective in oxygen-containing polymers, where there is a char to form: polyesters, polyamides, polycarbonates and their blends.

Their great advantage is that they do not produce the corrosive and toxic gases that halogens do, and they produce much less smoke. Their disadvantage is that they need a char-forming polymer to work with. In a pure polyolefin there is nothing to char, so a phosphorus system alone is ineffective and has to be combined with a char former or a different mechanism.

The common commercial forms are red phosphorus, which is cheap and effective and coloured, and organophosphorus compounds such as resorcinol bis diphenyl phosphate, which are colourless and used where appearance matters. The colour is often the deciding factor: red phosphorus is the most cost-effective option in a black compound and unusable in a white one.

Phosphorus systems also plasticise. Many of them are liquids or low melting solids that reduce the melt viscosity and the glass transition temperature, which can be an advantage in processing and a disadvantage in heat resistance. A part that meets the flammability specification but softens ten degrees earlier is not the same part.

Aluminium hydroxide and magnesium hydroxide

Metal hydroxides work by endothermic decomposition. Aluminium hydroxide releases about 1 050 joules per gram as it decomposes to alumina and water around 200 C, and the water dilutes the flame. Magnesium hydroxide does the same at a higher temperature, around 330 C, which makes it suitable for polymers processed above the decomposition point of ATH.

The loadings are the problem. To absorb enough heat to stop a flame, ATH has to be present at 55 to 65 percent by weight. At that loading the polymer is a binder rather than a matrix, and tensile strength, elongation and impact all fall sharply. The chart on the left shows the shape: ATH loses 48 percent of its tensile strength at 40 parts, where a halogenated system has lost 24.

Tensile strength retained falling with flame retardant loading for three systems, plus a bar chart of what decides which system is chosen
Left: the mechanical price of each system. Right: what decides the choice.

The filler also changes processing. A 60 percent filled compound has a viscosity several times that of the base resin, so it needs more torque, runs hotter and fills more slowly. It is abrasive, so screws and barrels wear faster. And it is moisture sensitive: ATH releases water at processing temperatures if it has absorbed moisture, which causes porosity and voids in the part.

The compensation is a coupling agent. A silane or a stearic acid treatment on the filler surface improves the bond to the polymer and recovers some of the lost mechanical properties. A treated ATH at 60 percent can outperform an untreated one at 55, which is why the surface treatment is specified on the data sheet and not left to the compounder.

The mechanical and processing price

Every flame retardant takes something away. The chart on the right ranks the cost: loading needed to pass at 28 percent, compound cost at 24, mechanical loss at 20, processing temperature at 14 and regulatory status at 10. The first three are technical and can be traded against each other; the last two are constraints.

Mechanical loss is the one that surprises designers. A V-0 rated polypropylene at 25 percent loading has a tensile strength about 20 percent below the unfilled grade, an elongation at break that may be a third of it and an impact strength that is lower again. A part designed on the unfilled data sheet and then converted to a flame retardant grade will fail, and it will fail in the way the data sheet predicted.

Processing temperature is a hard constraint rather than a trade. ATH cannot survive above about 200 C, so it is not an option for polyamide or polycarbonate. Magnesium hydroxide extends that to about 330 C, which covers more polymers but not all. A halogenated system can go higher, at the cost of the corrosion risk if the temperature runs away.

Regulatory status is the constraint that cannot be engineered around. Halogen free is a market requirement in electronics and transport, and it is written into customer specifications rather than into law. A compound that meets every technical requirement and contains a brominated compound will still be rejected by a customer who has specified halogen free, and that is a specification decision rather than a technical one.

Choosing and qualifying a compound

Start from the test, not from the chemistry. UL 94 V-0 is a vertical burn test on a small bar with a defined flame application. The limiting oxygen index measures the minimum oxygen concentration that supports combustion. The glow wire test measures ignition resistance at a hot wire. The cone calorimeter measures heat release rate. Each of these tests a different behaviour, and a compound that passes one may fail another.

Then check the thickness. UL 94 ratings are thickness dependent, and a V-0 at 1.6 mm is not a V-0 at 0.8 mm. A compound that is rated at the thickness of the actual part is a different product from one rated at twice that thickness, and the data sheet will say which. Specifying the rating without the thickness is the most common error in flame retardant specifications.

Then check the properties that the part actually uses. If the part is a clip, impact strength matters. If it is a housing, stiffness and heat resistance matter. If it is a cable jacket, elongation and ageing matter. A compound should be selected on the properties that the design depends on, with the flammability rating as a filter rather than as the only criterion.

Finally, run the compound in the actual tool before committing. Flame retardant compounds flow differently, cool differently and shrink differently, and a tool balanced for the unfilled resin may not balance for the filled one. A short trial on the production tool is the only way to know, and it is cheaper than discovering it at the first production run.

System Mechanism Caricamento Main limitation
Brominated with antimony Gas phase radical quench 12 to 18 phr Corrosive smoke, halogen free rules it out
Chlorinated Gas phase radical quench 20 to 30 phr Higher loading, same smoke issue
Red phosphorus Condensed phase char 8 to 15 phr Colour, only in char forming polymers
Organophosphorus Condensed phase char 15 to 25 phr Plasticises, needs a char forming resin
Aluminium hydroxide Endothermic, water release 55 to 65 phr Mechanical loss, 200 C ceiling
Magnesium hydroxide Endothermic, water release 55 to 65 phr Same loading, 330 C ceiling

Table 1 — Six systems and the trade each one makes

Test Standard What it tells you
Vertical burn UL 94 V-0, V-1, V-2 Whether a small flame self-extinguishes, at a stated thickness
Limiting oxygen index ISO 4589 The oxygen concentration needed to sustain burning
Glow wire IEC 60695-2-12 Resistance to ignition from a hot wire, used in appliances
Cone calorimeter ISO 5660 Heat release rate, the number fire engineers use
Smoke density ISO 5659 Optical density of smoke, critical for transport

Table 2 — Five tests, five different questions

What loading does UL 94 V-0 need?

Twelve to eighteen parts per hundred for a halogenated system, fifteen to twenty five for phosphorus, and fifty five to sixty five for a metal hydroxide. The rating is also thickness dependent, so the loading only means something at a stated wall thickness.

Can I use aluminium hydroxide in polyamide?

No. ATH decomposes around 200 C, below the processing temperature of polyamide. Magnesium hydroxide decomposes around 330 C and is the metal hydroxide option for higher temperature polymers.

Why does my flame retardant part feel weaker?

Because it is. A V-0 polypropylene at 25 percent loading loses about 20 percent of its tensile strength and more of its elongation and impact. The part has to be designed on the flame retardant grade's data, not on the unfilled resin's.

Is halogen free a legal requirement?

In most markets it is a customer and market requirement rather than a law. It is written into electronics and transport specifications, and a compound that contains a brominated additive will be rejected regardless of its technical performance.

What is the difference between LOI and UL 94?

LOI measures the oxygen concentration needed to sustain burning, as a number. UL 94 is a pass or fail vertical burn test at a stated thickness. A compound can have a good LOI and still fail UL 94 because the tests measure different behaviour.

Do I need to trial a flame retardant compound in the tool?

Yes. Filled compounds flow, cool and shrink differently, and a tool balanced for the unfilled resin may not balance for the filled one. A short trial on the production tool is cheaper than a failed first run.

A flame retardant grade that fails the drawing?

Send the wall thickness, the rating you need and the properties the part depends on. We will tell you which system can meet all three and what it will cost in the other columns.

Ask about flame retardant compounds

Hi there! I'm John, dad and hero to awesome kid. By day, I'm a plastics manufacturing vet — injection molding, extrusion and vacuum forming — who went from factory floors to technical management. Here to share what I've learned—let's grow together!
it_ITIT

Chiedete un preventivo rapido

Inviare disegni e requisiti dettagliati via

Emial: [email protected]

Oppure compilate il modulo di contatto qui sotto: